Month: January 2014

Reason #32: In your 50 years

53 Reasons NOT To Believe Khuzaima Qutbuddin

(From the author of the ‘Black & White’, post #18)

I know not the job responsibilities of a Dawat dignitary but both my heart and intellect dictate that the prime focus must be to bring Mumineen closer to their Dai and Moula.

I am a simple Mumin, one of many. We look back at the last 50 years and recollect who has affectionately brought us nearer to Syedna Mohammed Burhanuddin RA. Our collective life experiences attest to Syedna Mufaddal Saifuddin TUS bringing us closer to Moula. During all these times, these moments, these memories, where were you? This is what Syedna Saifuddin TUS, His Eminence (HE) did and continues to do for me. What did you do?

1.       When I was born, HE helped my parents get my name from Moula RA. You were busy giving your own.

2.       HE made my parents understand that Deeni Taaleem preceded secular…

View original post 225 more words


Reason #30: Where is the Quality?

53 Reasons NOT To Believe Khuzaima Qutbuddin

Having a majority is not in itself proof of Haqq. There is no disputing this position. However, for the leader of either a majority or a minority, the standing of his companions, the quality of his supporters, is a reflection upon himself. It could be said that, in part, the merit of your associates is comment on your own character and vision.

Hudaat Kiraam RA have always been surrounded by their noble disciples and followers, even if they were few in number.  History has noted that though Ameerul Muminen Moulana Ali SA had few devoted supporters of his cause after the demise of Rasoolullah SA, they were publicly known to be of righteous character and elevated status. They had served Rasoolullah SA with diligence and sacrifice, especially in the early battles of Islam. This is especially apparent in the time of Ameerul Mumineen’s khilafat when he received the support…

View original post 485 more words

Reason #31: Misaaq is to Moula, not to Mazoon

53 Reasons NOT To Believe Khuzaima Qutbuddin

Misaaq is to Moula, not to Mazoon

From their website:

The rutba is fully named Mazoon al-Mutlaq because of the high platform that it shares with the Dai al-Mutlaq. It is a rutba for which we give an oath of allegiance in the misaaq alongside the Dai.

 We are mumineen, true followers of Syedna Mohammad Burhanuddin, and true adherents to the misaaq, fulfilling our qasam of walayat to Dai Mazoon Mukasir

 The fitnat people claim that Burhanuddin Mola ye Qutbuddin Mola ne “reva dida”, keeping him Mazoon only in zahir/outwardly form. If this were true, how could Burhanuddin Mola continue to take Qutbuddin Mola’s name in the misaaq oath which is the basis of every mumin’s imaan?

The misaaq is indeed the fundamental pact by which a Mumin acquires salvation. However, that pact is solely between Moula and Mumin. As the misaaq text clearly states, “This…

View original post 208 more words

# 29: Regarding the Photograph With Syedna Taher Saifuddin RA.

53 Reasons NOT To Believe Khuzaima Qutbuddin

On his website, Khuzeima Qutbuddin has alleged that a photograph taken with him, Syedna Mohammed Burhanuddin al-Hayy al-Muqaddas RA, and Syedna Taher Saifuddin RA is proof of his alleged nass considering that Syedna Taher Saifuddin RA waited 10 minutes to find him and bring him for the picture. He and his children write,

“This picture was not a coincidence. Syedna Taher Saifuddin summoned Syedna Qutbuddin and waited for ten minutes. He could have also summoned any other, or all, of the brothers in Surat. He did not A picture is worth a thousand words.”

Again, interpreting a sharaf as an indication of nass is an interesting argument. In response please view this video.

View original post

Reason #28: Qasm by Quran

53 Reasons NOT To Believe Khuzaima Qutbuddin

From the FatemiDawat website:

“Syedna Burhanuddin’s Mazoon of 50 years is swearing an oath on the Quran that Syedna Burhanuddin did nass on him”

A video has been posted which shows the claimant holding up a Quran, one which apparently belonged to Syedna Taher Saifuddin and disrespectfully waving it about, saying that he swears by ‘this Quran’, that he is the 53rd Dai. This is reminiscent of what happened during the battle of Siffeen. Syedna Al-Qadi Al Noman RA explains in detail that when Moawiya saw that the battle was going to be lost and that victory was soon to be in favour of Amirul Mumineen, he craftily placed the Quran on the heads of spears and called both sides to resort to the command of the Quran. He had no intention to establish the truth or to clarify who the rightful Imam was. Rather his sole design in…

View original post 219 more words

Reason #27: Rebuttal on Mazoon’s “Absolute Truthfulness”

53 Reasons NOT To Believe Khuzaima Qutbuddin

From the FatemiDawat website:

Syedna Khuzaima Qutbuddin was Syedna Mohammed Burhanuddin’s Mazoon until his wafat. No one can dispute this. Mazoon’s aala shaan is attested in Dawat kitaabo. Therefore, you must accept that what Syedi Mazoon Saheb is saying about Nass is the truth (and that what shehzadas are claiming counter to that is fabricated).

Following Syedna Burhanuddin, Syedna Qutbuddin possessed the highest shaan in Dawat in rank, in imaan, ilm, akhlaaq, taqwa, riyazat, bandagi, sabar, siyasat, guidance, vision, wisdom, fairness, integrity, sincerity, khidmat, compassion, caring for mumineen’s well-being. Balance. Eg. wa’azo and bayaano, dealings with complicated Dawat issues in past (eg. Udaipur), Dawat ni khidmat ma jaanfishani, right guidance of hundreds of individual mumineen, founding and supervision of clean charities such as Zahra Hasanaat and QJSP (Qutbi Jubilee Scholarship Program).

As has been the case all along, empty claims have been the norm on this website. Numerous assertions have…

View original post 736 more words

Reason #26: The So called ‘Amanat’ of Nass

53 Reasons NOT To Believe Khuzaima Qutbuddin

The FatemiDawat website (Q&A section) tries to justify the announcement of Nass by Khuzaima on the 17th/18th of January 2014:

“Why did Qutbuddin Maula TUS wait until now to disclose that he is the true mansoos and not two years ago?

Qutbuddin Mawla obeyed the farmaan of Syedna Burhanuddin RA and kept his nass private/khangi.  Two years ago, when Shehzada Qaid Johar bhaisaheb announced that nass was conferred on Shehzada Mufaddal bhaisaheb, Qutbuddin Maula maintained his charge of secrecy and patiently waited for Syedna’s return from London to speak in private. Then it became known that Syedna has suffered a debilitating stroke impairing his speech and awareness. With sabr and fortitude, Qutbuddin mawla kept obeying the farmaan to keep his nass secret with the hope that Syedna Burhanuddin would recover from the stroke and correct the falsehood done during his illness”

Do the words “disclose now” refer to 18th January 2014…

View original post 1,251 more words